How Do Reviews Help My Insurance Agency’s SEO?

Reviews are a powerful tool when it comes to building your insurance agency's online presence. Here's how they improve your SEO.

Share This Post

The first step in achieving success as an independent insurance agency is expanding your digital footprint. You might list your company name, logo, services, and team members to allow shoppers the best, most transparent look at your agency, but, ultimately, it may not be your profile alone that sells insurance shoppers on your agency. So, what are shoppers looking for? Reviews, of course! Reviews are a powerful way to help your agency’s SEO.

Are reviews that important?

Positive or negative, reviews are the bread and butter of any agency. In fact, 97% of shoppers use online reviews to determine whether to pursue a product or service, and 50% of shoppers contribute with a review of their own. Reviews are the ultimate reflection of your agency’s capabilities, which means great service is rewarded with a shiny five stars and, by extension, more organic traffic to your site.

“I’ve never dealt with an agency more professional and more caring about their clients and how they can help them. They are always striving to make you happy and look out for your needs and to make sure you’re taken care of. When you deal with them it’s like dealing with true family. Recommend them all the time even to people out of town.”

— Five-star review of Ingram Insurance & Real Estate

Not only do reviews allow for a clear route to your agency, but they also boost your overall SEO performance. According to a study performed by SearchEngineWatch.com in 2016, reviews represent just under 10% of all ranking factors on Google. Farming positive reviews gives your agency an automatic leg-up online by lending your agency credibility (via the site crawlers cataloging your agency website and determining your relevance for SEO placement) and boosting your ranking on SERP (search results pages). To top it all off, a positive experience generates brand recognition, meaning your shoppers might be more willing to recommend your services to friends and family.

How do I get more reviews?

While reviews are primarily up to the shopper and their experience, you should always be encouraging new customers to leave their honest review on your Advantage profile. This is made simpler by logging into your account, copying the sharing link under Ratings and including it any customer outreach efforts, like email newsletter footers. You don’t just have to stick to your Advantage profile, though—shoppers should also be encouraged to leave reviews on alternative sites, like Facebook, Google, Yelp, etc.

“I had a complicated insurance need that other agents struggled to deal with and my agent solved my problem practically overnight. It was easy and my agent gave me fantastic advice and service!”

—Five-star review of Norton Insurance Agency, LLC

The purpose of reviews is to get your agency’s name and mission out there through the experience of satisfied shoppers. That means wherever a review can be left, a review should be left.

What do I do about negative reviews?

Negative reviews are inevitable in business, but there are ways to turn all that negative into a positive. The best rule of thumb is to determine where the shopper’s experience went wrong and strategize how to correct it through quality customer service. While you cannot remove reviews on Google (this is to give shoppers full transparency), you can put your best foot forward to find a solution and encourage the shopper to remove their own review.

Enhancing your insurance agency’s SEO through positive reviews is a game-changer in today’s digital landscape. By actively encouraging satisfied clients to share their experiences, you not only boost your online visibility but also build trust with potential customers. Don’t let your agency blend into the background—take control of your online reputation today. Request a free demo to discover how the Advantage program can help you harness the power of client reviews and elevate your agency’s SEO performance.​

Discover your Advantage

Let's us give you a demo to find which subscription is right for you.